Press "Enter" to skip to content

I Am Legend: Comparing All Three Movie Adaptations Based On How Close They Are To The Novel







(Picture credit ranking: Warner Bros. Photos)


Glance, I comprehend it’s cool to chat about the total movies that dangle been manufactured from Philip Ok. Dick reports, like Blade Runner (both the distinctive and Blade Runner 2049) and Entire Pick, but I mediate we must chat extra about Richard Matheson, because he had a graceful sizable line of diversifications, too. What Needs Can also Reach, The Improbable Timorous Man, Duel, hell, even the movie Precise Steel, change into primarily based off of 1 in every of his extra obscure Twilight Zone episodes, called “Steel”. But if we’re going to chat about any Richard Matheson legend that had the most have an effect on, then we must chat about I Am Yarn, which has no longer one, but THREE movie diversifications.

Now, all americans knows about the 2007 version of I Am Yarn starring Will Smith, but sooner than that, there change into the 1971 movie, The Omega Man, starring Charlton Heston, and sooner than that, there change into the 1964 movie, The Final Man on Earth, starring Vincent Rate. Now, truthfully, no longer one amongst the flicks dangle advance even shut to being as accurate as the book, but one of the crucial flicks dangle a minimal of advance shut to being like the book. But, which movie did the finest job of translating Richard Matheson’s account vampire legend to the astronomical show conceal conceal? Properly, you’re about to search out out.

Oh, and predominant spoilers for both the book and the motion photographs up forward.

(Picture credit ranking: American World Photos)

When put next To The Region Of I Am Yarn

When a book is personalized to movie, rather quite a lot of fans are looking out for to survey the movie’s map to be a minimal of equivalent to the unconventional’s. So, which of the three motion photographs is the closest?

The Final Man On Earth’s Region

No longer to be perplexed with the pleasing, now-cancelled comedy, The Final Man on Earth, The Final Man on Earth movie is set a scientist who goes out by day and kills vampires (though they shamble like zombies), and hides in his dwelling at night while the vampires bang on his windows. He befriends a canines (which dies), then befriends a girl, who is truly an evolved vampire. And then, extra of the evolved vampires extinguish our hero. The finish.

Moreover the zombie-like vampires (that would dangle impressed Romero’s The Evening of the Residing Unnecessary), the the leisure of the movie is de facto graceful shut to the book, even alongside side the backstory with our hero’s daughter, and his vampiric top-notch friend looking out for to extinguish him. It’s nowhere shut to as enticing as the unconventional, but map-wise, it’s graceful equivalent.

The Omega Man’s Region

Charlton Heston performs a scientist who drives spherical at some stage in the day, and fights these albino mutants wearing hoods called “The family” at night. They are looking out for to extinguish him because he represents “science” and so they abominate science, because they mediate it transformed them into the mutants they’re currently. Heston meets some folks alongside the style, fights the mutants, and then dies with his fingers unfold out like Jesus on the disagreeable. The finish. So, certainly, The Omega Man borrows ideas from the book, but that’s about it.

 I Am Yarn’s Region

An Military virologist (Will Smith) patrols Unique York as a loner while vampires, acknowledged as Darkish Seekers, are attempting to extinguish him. Smith will get a canines, which dies, and then the vampires evolve, and he blows himself and the top vampire up with a grenade. Properly, that is, for certain, reckoning on what version of the ending you survey. The finish.

Winner for Region:   Whereas I Am Yarn does dangle the rapid vampires from the book, The Final Man on Earth is closer, map-wise, so as that wins in this class.

(Picture credit ranking: Warner Bros.)

When put next To The I Am Yarn Protagonist

A man named Robert Neville is the one real real survivor in the book. So, what’s he like in the motion photographs?

The Final Man On Earth’s Protagonist

Robert Morgan (Morgan?) is a scientist in the movie, and he kills vampires, but Vincent Prince does NOT watch like a vampire-killer. He’s extra scientist than soldier. Neville in the book is badass, killing vampires with stakes and crucifixes. Morgan does use garlic in the movie, though, so as that’s equivalent to the book, a minimal of.

The Omega Man’s Protagonist

This Robert Neville can even be a scientist, but he’s one who kicks ass and shoots his rifle out the window. What else would you query from Charlton Heston?

I Am Yarn’s Protagonist

Robert Neville is a virologist in this one. He kicks ass, but he also seems graceful neat, so he’s an acceptable in-between.

Winner for Protagonist:  Properly… None of them are certainly all that shut to the wise killer in the unconventional, but once I needed to salvage one… then I’d salvage The Omega Man, but largely since he seems the most profitable in strive in opposition to.

(Picture credit ranking: Warner Bros. Photos)

When put next To I Am Yarn’s Vampires

I Am Yarn is a vampire legend. So, which movie will get that the most accurate?

The Final Man On Earth’s Vampires

The Final Man on Earth has “vampires”, but they switch like zombies. It’s unique.

The Omega Man’s Vampires

The Omega Man has albino mutants wearing cloaks. Positively no longer vampires.

I Am Yarn’s Vampires

I Am Yarn has vampires (or Hemocytes), but they’re no longer like, used vampires, and in the book, they’re used vampires. The disagreeable (or the Well-known individual of David) hurts them. So, shut, but no longer shut enough.

Winner for vampires:  If truth be told, I mediate they all lose when when compared with the book, but I bet the Darkseekers in I Am Yarn are the closest. I allege.

(Picture credit ranking: Warner Bros.)

The Subject issues When put next To I Am Yarn

Subject issues of what isolation does to a individual, and the thought that of by no diagram giving up hope are all topics in I Am Yarn. So, which movie will get closest to these topics?

The Final Man On Earth’s Subject issues

This movie does salvage into the thought that of how loneliness modifications a individual, but it’s no longer nearly as nice because it is in the book.

The Omega Man’s Subject issues

The idea that of feeling the pressures of isolation certainly weigh closely on this version of the legend, and the actions of Heston’s character are in an instant related to his must no longer be alone.

I Am Yarn’s Subject issues

I Am Yarn tries to assemble the identical part as The Omega Man by diagram of showcasing the outcomes of loneliness. But it’s no longer as nice as The Omega Man, which is graceful, since I mediate Will Smith is a significantly better actor than Charlton Heston, so it wants to be the script’s fault.

Winner for Subject issues:  Surprisingly, The Omega Man captures the topics of the book the finest, even whether it is the silliest of the three movies.

(Picture credit ranking: American World Photos)

When put next To The Ending Of I Am Yarn

Within the tip of the book, our hero is now feared by the vampires, but he’s outnumbered. So, he takes a pill to extinguish himself, and thinks, amusingly, about how he has change into a story himself since, as the final man on earth, he has change into practically mythical, attributable to this truth the title.

The Final Man On Earth’s Ending

The finish of The Final Man on Earth sees the evolved vampires (though, they’re hardly ever superpowered), arriving to extinguish Neville, er, I mean Morgan, because they survey him as a threat. He dies very un-heroically, but oh, well. No longer no longer as a lot because it’s extra or less equivalent to the book. Composed, he positively doesn’t seem legendary.

The Omega Man’s Ending

Neville fights the top of the family, and he will get betrayed by any individual he trusted. He will get speared, and then dies in a fountain. Um… okay.

I Am Yarn’s Ending

Neville blows himself and the top vampire up with a grenade, but in doing so, he has given the survivors a medication, that diagram there is hope for the long speed. Um… okay again?

Winner for The Ending:  NONE of the motion photographs dangle the incredible ending of the book, but, by default, I bet I certainly must give it to The Final Man on Earth, which certainly sucks because that ending is no longer accurate, but it’s the closet to the unconventional.

The Overall Winner: Surprisingly, I certainly dangle a tie between The Final Man on Earth and The Omega Man (Also, how ironic is it that the one certainly CALLED I Am Yarn is the least just like the book?). Composed, The Final Man on Earth certainly has vampires (I bet), so I bet I feel that one the winner.

But what dangle you ever suspect? Comprise you considered all three movies? For data on motion photographs fee streaming for when that you just’ll seemingly be feeling just like the living boring, or upcoming scare motion photographs, guarantee to swing by right here normally.

Lover of Avatar (The Final Airbender, no longer the blue folks), video games, and anything 90s, he’ll talk your ear off about Godzilla, so don’t salvage him started.

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.