By 2002, many of the most main American television networks had found out success with Stephen King adaptations, as CBS, ABC, and FOX all airing a miniseries or TV movie in line with the creator’s works. NBC used to be an exception for an extremely long time, however they in some plot got the message – and the decision used to be made to return to King’s seminal printed contemporary: Carrie.
Wanting the variation rights to the e-book, the network opened negotiations with MGM – which held the rights following the 1981 acquisition of United Artists, which produced director Brian De Palma’s Carrie in 1976. Unfortunately, there devour been some sticking ingredients. Based on Bryan Fuller (in a 2006 interview with Droll E book Resources), there used to be a war referring to what the remake ought to be – both a standalone TV movie, or a series-launcher. Stated Fuller,
With Star Shuffle Generations director David Carson on board, the project went into production in British Columbia, Canada, and Carrie aired on NBC honest previous Halloween in 2002 – and while the hassle ended up being a gigantic flop within the ratings, it’s without a doubt a remake with a intelligent legacy. No longer easiest does it conceal ground within the e-book that isn’t featured within the conventional usual, it sports an ending that radically adjustments some key takeaways from the e-book. At its core it’s restful the memoir of the tortured and abused teenage telepath who loses it on accelerate night, however it without a doubt’s an interpretation that makes for intelligent dissection on this week’s Adapting Stephen King.
How David Carson’s Carrie Differs From Brian De Palma’s Carrie
In adapting Carrie for the usual characteristic movie, screenwriter Lawrence Cohen made the decision to simplify the discipline materials – taking the epistolary contemporary and forming it into a ragged linear account. Fortuitously, the 2002 TV movie is the more or less remake that tries to construct its devour identification, and regarded one of many gigantic programs it in reality works to pause that is by changing up the structure.
Bryan Fuller’s teleplay doesn’t precisely replicate Stephen King’s contemporary, as there aren’t any courtroom scenes and Sue Snell (Kandyse McClure) isn’t featured writing a e-book about her experiences, however there may be a framing application in play with a character named Det. John Mulchaey (Firestarter’s David Keith) interrogating survivors and attempting to determine what took put within the aftermath. (Jasmine Guy additionally filmed scenes taking half in a psychic investigator, though they devour been all decrease before broadcast.)
The remake also restores a scene from the e-book that used to be in the initiating going to be extinct because the opening sequence of Brian De Palma’s movie – particularly a flashback to Carrie White’s childhood when she spies on her female teenage neighbor sunbathing topless. The young Carrie (Jodelle Ferland) asks her about her chest, and she is free with info, however Margaret White (Patricia Clarkson) interrupts and drags her daughter inside. This ends within the abused lady having even handed one of her first necessary psychic occasions, which sees the White house pelted by rocks falling from the sky. The movie in reality goes a minute too a long way within the depiction of these occasions, and essentially makes it seem just like the residing house is the explicit goal of a meteor bathe.
The ending of David Carson’s Carrie deviates from Stephen King’s memoir in just a few programs (more on that in a moment), however there are about a basic programs in which it’s more devoted than the 1976 movie. The first is that the destruction wrought by the titular protagonist (Angela Bettis) is no longer only puny to the classmate flambé at accelerate. Her psychic skills continue to salvage all kinds of chaos as she makes her plot from the college gymnasium to her house, in conjunction with blowing up a gas location, and the 2002 movie brings that to lifestyles with some… downhearted visible outcomes.
Also of demonstrate? Sympathetic trainer Pass over Desjardin (Rena Sofer) survives the accelerate assault within the remake – unlike her counterpart, Betty Buckley’s Pass over Collins, within the usual.
One visible elevate out that if truth be told does look sizable within the more up-to-the-minute version of Carrie is the loss of life of Margaret White. The Brian De Palma movie didn’t devour the sources or abilities accessible to depict the loss of life of Carrie’s mom as it is described within the e-book, and thus her reign of fanatical terror came to an pause with her being impaled by a cloud of kitchen knives. As in the initiating written by Stephen King, Carrie kills Margaret by utilizing telekinesis to crush her heart, and that’s exactly what occurs within the remake.
How David Carson’s Carrie Differs From The E book
Brian De Palma’s Carrie is an exceptionally devoted live-gallop place close on the usual contemporary (as illustrious in my usual Adapting Stephen King column), however for all of the reasons mentioned above, David Carson’s movie is in some basic programs a long way more devoted. The remake updates the atmosphere to invent the memoir up-to-the-minute, and there are certain minor adjustments that approach along side that, however the fact that it is nearly a fat half of-hour longer means that it has the trusty estate to bring a long way more discipline topic from the online page to the mask.
As identified by the director on the movie’s filmmaker commentary video display, however, there may be one entirely big deviation from the availability discipline topic within the 2002 adaptation, and it stems from the fact that the movie used to be in half deliberate as a backdoor pilot. In Stephen King’s contemporary, Carrie is killed when she returns house and she is stabbed by her mom, however that’s no longer the formula issues play out within the remake, as Carson explains:
In David Carson’s Carrie, the protagonist returns house covered in blood, and as but any other of getting showered (setting up a parallel with the shocking sequence within the first act), she opts for a hot bathtub. Margaret enters the lavatory feigning empathy and kindness, however she then tries to drown her daughter by keeping her head underwater. It’s while right here’s happening that Carrie crushes her mom’s heart inside her chest, and for a moment it looks to be prefer it is too gradual for the tortured teen – however then Sue Snell arrives and affords her CPR.
Relish within the e-book, Sue will get a psychic flash of Carrie’s memories, however then the drowned lady wakes up and spits the water from her lungs. After getting a ghastly blonde wig for the eponymous character to place on, Sue makes the decision to bring the telekinetic assassin to a brand contemporary metropolis where she can delivery a brand contemporary lifestyles, while also making plans to return house so that she can participate within the investigation of the accelerate and serve conceal up what in reality took put.
Is It Staunch Of The King?
In arguably the most controversial e-book that Stephen King has ever written is Rage – a contemporary he printed below his pseudonym, Richard Bachman. The memoir aspects a protagonist who initiates a college taking pictures, and it is the one real contemporary King has let exit of print, the creator believing that it is easiest omitted of circulation.
Carrie is nowhere advance as rude as Rage, and the supernatural parts devour the elevate out of making the discipline materials more delicious, however there may be a comparability to be made with the discipline materials. Put aside in extra life like terms, Stephen King’s seminal contemporary is the memoir of a bullied and abused lady who violently lashes out when she is pushed too a long way. We without a doubt sympathize with Carrie White, because the horrors that she suffers are hideous and unprovoked, however the memoir also never tells and even asks the reader to condone her habits.
This is the first aspect that will get below my pores and skin about David Carson’s Carrie. On top of extra stripping away the paradox and thriller referring to the intentions of Sue Snell and toning down the insanity of Margaret White (Patricia Clarkson goes nowhere advance as big as Piper Laurie), the TV movie treats Carrie White as a sufferer to the very pause – one we ought to be delighted will get saved as she is whisked off to ingredients unknown to live a brand contemporary lifestyles.
There may be a certain residing off and elevate out right here. If the TV movie used to be going to goal as a backdoor pilot, it required an open ending that may perchance allow the memoir to be expanded, and that wasn’t going to happen if Carrie White devour been killed. Without the memoir continuing, however, and the TV movie standing as its devour aspect, it’s an adaptation with a conclusion that doesn’t effectively satisfy the intent of the availability discipline topic.
Additional hindering 2002’s Carrie from ageing effectively is what’s going to even be courteously called an overambitious utilization of visible outcomes. One can treasure the movie going attend to the e-book and that contains the titular protagonist’s path of destruction going a long way previous honest the college… however in reality visualizing it with the budget accessible means that there may be half of the movie with the obedient of a PlayStation 2 sport.
In the October 2006 CBR interview, Bryan Fuller recalls an downhearted push/pull between big demands and puny sources:
It’s a remake that is inaccurate in just a few programs, however it without a doubt does devour its tough qualities – the one real being its diversions from the Brian De Palma incarnation and the attempts at honing even nearer to the availability discipline topic. That technique will not be any decrease than a feather in its cap no longer possessed by the 2d remake that used to be launched in theaters 11 years later… however that’s a discipline I obtained’t salvage into unless my column residing to be printed on July 27.
How To Look David Carson’s Carrie
Whereas you happen to’re building the Final Stephen King assortment and/or only a fan of physical media, David Carson’s Carrie will most up-to-date a minute of a challenge for you, as it’s easiest been made launched on Blu-ray once (packaged by Bawl Manufacturing unit as a double characteristic with The Rage: Carrie 2), and it has gone out of print. It’s a long way accessible on DVD, however while you’re hunting for HD your easiest wager for viewing is to plod digital. The movie is streaming with ads on PlutoTV, and you may perchance lease or place close it on Vudu or iTunes. It’s also on Google Play, however only for take hold of.
Looking forward, I’ll be exploring but one other first for Stephen King adaptations: the first ever produced in a foreign language. In 2003, Sri Lankan born Indian filmmaker Balu Mahendra took on the challenge of making his devour interpretation of the radical Anguish, and his movie Julie Ganapathi steadily is the discipline of subsequent week’s Adapting Stephen King. Peek for it within the CinemaBlend movie half on Wednesday, and meanwhile you may perchance click on during the banners under to peep all of the previous installments of this column.
NJ native who calls LA house; lives in a Dreamatorium. A decade-plus CinemaBlend aged; forever fascinated referring to the occupation he’s dreamt of since seventh grade.